Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Dave Matheny
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Dave Matheny

Dave Matheny Ins Agcy Inc

122 E Main St
P O Box 366
Carmi, IL 62821-0366

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


122 E Main St
P O Box 366
Carmi, IL 62821-0366



July is wedding season and it might bring up memories of your wedding. We offer insurance for personal articles policies and would love to talk with you about insuring that wedding ring or other valuable items such as art, jewelry, or collectibles.

Dave Matheny State Farm has served the Carmi area for approximately three decades. We not only help our Illinois Good Neighbors but we are licensed to help Indiana residents as well. My team prides itself on offering friendly and personalized service to customers in and around White County and helping them create coverage to match their Life, Auto, and Home Insurance needs. We will even cover your furry friend with Pet Insurance!

Outside of the office, I am deeply involved in the community. I am a proud member and past board member of the Carmi Kiwanis Club, and I am a Carmi Chamber of Commerce member. I graduated from Millikin University and hold a CLU designation. As a long-time area resident who grew up in Pawnee, IL and lived in Lincoln, Normal, and Jacksonville, FL, I am familiar with customers unique needs. I support a variety of local charities and organizations and give back where possible, including coaching basketball and baseball teams.

If you are ready to get started on creating a personalized insurance plan, I hope you will reach out to my team. We are here to help and looking forward to serving out Good Neighbors!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

How to get rid of cigarette smell

Cigarette smoke removal can be a stubborn task. Learn tips to help remove smoke smell from car or home surfaces.

The Real Consequences of Drunk Driving

What's at stake if you're caught drunk driving? A lot. These tips help you avoid the dangers of drinking and driving.

When should I update my estate plan?

Marriage, death and divorce are, of course, reasons to update an estate plan. We review other times to review what's included in this financial document.

View More Articles

Dave Matheny State Farm is located in Carmi, Illinois, and proudly helps area residents and those in Indiana obtain Pet, Life, and Auto Insurance plans that work for them. We are dedicated to rendering personalized service, and with approximately three decades of experience, I look forward to addressing your coverage needs and concerns. Whether you reside in Crossville, Grayville, or Mill Shoals, my team is here to extend its services. We look forward to getting to know you, Good Neighbors.

People make all the difference when it comes to insurance, and these friendly and talented women will help you every step of the way. Call or click today for a free auto or home insurance quote.

Amanda Hall State Farm Agent Team Member

Amanda Hall

Office Manager

Hello, I'm Amanda! I joined the Dave Matheny State Farm team in 2007 and help Good Neighbors with Auto, Life, Business, Home, and Renters Insurance needs. I am adventurous and funny, and I attended Carmi-White County High School. A fun fact about me is that I lived overseas for three years, and I enjoy being with my family and pets and spending time outdoors.
Lisa Ackerman State Farm Agent Team Member

Lisa Ackerman

Customer Service Representative

Hello, my name is Lisa, and I have been with Dave Matheny State Farm since 1999. I love getting to know our Good Neighbors in Carmi and helping them with personalized Auto, Life, Home, and Renters Insurance. I attended Harrisburg High School and have a variety of interests including cooking, baking, traveling, and riding on a motorcycle.
Tammy Matheny State Farm Agent Team Member

Tammy Matheny

Office Associate

Hi there! I'm Tammy, and I bring over 12 years of valuable experience in the insurance industry to our team. As a licensed professional, I specialize in assisting our customers with their Auto Insurance needs, ensuring they receive top-notch service and comprehensive coverage. One thing you'll quickly learn about me is that I'm easygoing by nature, but when it comes to advocating for our customers, I'm not afraid to step up to the plate. Ensuring our customers are well taken care of is always my top priority, and I'll go to bat for them to make sure they are confident in their insurance coverage. When I'm not at work, you can usually find me spending quality time with my grandkids and beloved dogs. Family is my world outside the office, and they keep me grounded and inspired every day. I'm thrilled to be part of this team, and I look forward to bringing my experience and dedication to serving our customers to the fullest extent possible.